Chapter 11: Symptom control and care towards the end of life
Skip chapter table of contents and go to main content
Dyspnoea (shortness of breath)
Definition
Breathlessness, or dyspnoea, is an unpleasant sensation defined as ‘a subjective experience of breathing discomfort that consists of qualitatively distinct sensations that vary in intensity’ (Parshall et al. [114], p.435). Some of the causes of breathlessness are listed in Box 11.4.
Box 11.4
Causes of dyspnoea
- Obstructing lung tumour
- Weakness and frailty
- Chest wall disease
- Lymphangitis carcinomatosis
- Diffuse lung pathology
- Infection
- Anaemia
- Heart failure
Approximately 70% of patients experience dyspnoea in the last 6 weeks of life and the distress associated with this symptom increases as death approaches (Ben‐Aharon et al. [10], Kamal et al. [72]). The causes of dyspnoea are often multifactorial (Ekstrom et al. [43]). In a prospective study, 50–65% of almost 600 patients attending a specialized palliative care unit had more frequent incidence of dyspnoea during the last 3 months of life (Ekstrom et al. [43]). Both patients and their families and carers report breathlessness to be a distressing symptom that can result in reduced quality of life, largely due to measures taken to manage this symptom (such as undertaking less physical activity), increased anxiety and depression, and the increased likelihood of hospital admissions (Simon et al. [138]). As death approaches, it still may be appropriate to try to manage reversible causes of breathlessness to manage the distress of this symptom, but dyspnoea can become refractory to intervention (Lacey [77]).
Pharmacological management with oral or parenteral opioids has been shown to help with the sensation of dyspnoea (Ben‐Aharon et al. [10], Chin and Booth [25], Dudgeon [42], Ekstrom et al. [43], Jennings et al. [70]). Benzodiazepines may be useful for reducing panic and anxiety but have not been evidenced to show an improvement in breathing (Simon et al. [138]). Oxygen therapy has been found to improve dyspnoea in patients who have been found to be hypoxic. In one study, approximately 10% of patients used oxygen therapy to help them with the distress of dyspnoea (Campbell et al. [19]).
Any reversible causes should be treated initially; however, if symptomatic relief is the aim of treatment, combining both pharmacological (Table 11.3) and non‐pharmacological interventions will improve symptom burden and quality of life (Currow et al. [32]). In patients who have low haemoglobin, a blood transfusion can help with the symptom of breathlessness. However, in some instances receiving a blood transfusion does not make the patient feel any better. Any ongoing interventions (such as blood transfusions) should only be considered if they are providing symptom relief and/or improving quality of life.
Table 11.3 Common medications used in the management of dyspnoea
Drug | Use |
---|---|
Oxygen | Reduce risk of hypoxia |
Salbutamol or terbutaline | Short‐acting bronchodilators |
Furosemide | Bronchodilator and diuretic |
Tiotropium or ipratropium bromide | Long‐acting bronchodilators |
Carbocisteine | Mucolytic – loosens secretions |
Theophylline | Bronchodilator – added if not getting benefit from optimum doses of inhaled bronchodilators |
Salmeterol | Long‐acting bronchodilator – may be used in combination with inhaled steroids |
Opioids | Reduce sensation of breathlessness |
Steroids | Reduce inflammation |
Lorazepam | Relaxant |
Nebulized saline | Loosen secretions |
Evidence‐based approaches
Anticipated patient outcomes
The patient will be free of symptoms that are distressing and/or having an impact on their quality of life.
Non‐pharmacological interventions
Non‐pharmacological interventions can give patients control and independence. Fan therapy creates air flow across the face, stimulating the skin and mucosa and causing activation of the second and third branches of the trigeminal nerve, resulting in relief of the sensation of breathlessness (Booth et al. [15]). Breathing retraining, different positioning, and cognitive–behavioural and self‐management techniques can all also help with breathlessness (Chin and Booth [25]).
Systematic reviews show limited evidence that acupuncture or acupressure are beneficial in dyspnoea (Towler et al. [152]). One study demonstrated that the use of acupuncture alone or in combination with morphine could offer some benefit to patients (Minchom et al. [94]). The Cambridge‐based Breathlessness Intervention Service recognizes key issues in the non‐pharmacological management of breathlessness including breathing techniques, mindfulness and relaxation (Booth et al. [16], Dudgeon [42]). While these techniques may be helpful, it may be difficult for patients to engage with them at the end of life. However, playing music is becoming increasingly common within holistic care delivered to those at the end of life (Clements‐Cortés [29]).
Non‐invasive ventilation (NIV) delivers respiratory support without the need for intubation. NIV usually provides positive
pressure via a tight‐fitting mask, nasal mask or helmet, to aid inspiration, help lung expansion and improve gaseous exchange. Modes and methods are discussed in detail in Chapter c12: Respiratory care, CPR and blood transfusion. NIV can be useful to support the patient's respiratory function during recovery from exacerbations of chronic conditions, during infective processes or in progressive respiratory disease. The aim would be to avoid intubation and invasive mechanical ventilation, which would be inappropriate for most patients at the end of life; therefore, NIV is often the ‘ceiling’ of treatment for advanced respiratory disease (Stevens and Laverty [145]).
Pre‐procedural considerations
It is useful to explore the extent of their breathlessness with the patient; how this is impacting them physically and psychologically; and how this is affecting their quality of life. Assessing previous effective methods used to control dyspnoea is useful as these can be implemented.
Procedure guideline 11.1
Management of dyspnoea (breathlessness)
For patients with refractory dyspnoea and severe distress in the terminal phase, sedation may need to be considered as an option to adequately control the symptom and to relieve suffering (Lacey [77]). Terminal sedition is explored further below.