Evidence‐based approaches

Rationale

Semen collection may be required for diagnostic and/or therapeutic purposes (Keogh [114], Pagana and Pagana [177]). Common reasons to collect semen include:
  • to evaluate the quality of the sperm
  • to investigate and evaluate the cause of infertility
  • to assess the success of vasectomy or vasectomy reversal (Pagana and Pagana [177])
  • cryopreservation of semen prior to treatments that may affect fertility, such as treatments for cancer (NICE [163], RCP, RCR and RCOG [205])
  • prior to artificial insemination (Hammarberg et al. [79])
  • for sperm donation (Van den Broek et al. [247]).

Principles of care

Studies have shown that male infertility can cause extreme loss of self‐esteem and impaired gender identity (Schmidt et al. [220]). There exists evidence on the importance of the relationship between body and mind in self‐identity and perception (Greil et al. [76]) and on the idea that male infertility threatens the perception of masculinity (Gannon et al. [64]).
However, much of the infertility literature suggests that the focus has previously been on the female rather than male partner so best practice is now that couples (opposite sex or same sex) having difficulty conceiving should be seen together as decisions made in relation to investigations and treatment affect both partners (HFEA [83]). Evidence‐based information should be made available to ensure informed decisions are made. Information can be given verbally and supplemented with written and/or audio‐visual information (NICE [163]).
For men and teenage young adults with cancer, semen collection is common as a means of fertility preservation. Education and information should be given to inform donors’ consent for cryopreservation. It is essential for patients to consider practical issues regarding how sperm is collected, stored and managed in the event of death prior to any cancer treatment (Pacey and Eiser [176]). Clinical judgement should be employed in the timing of this consultation, but doing so at the earliest opportunity is encouraged.
Whatever the reason for collecting semen, the donor should have adequate verbal and written information. They should also have time and counselling to consider the decision, reflect on the consequences of donation and fully understand the process of how their semen will be collected.

Methods of semen collection

Masturbation

Collecting semen for sperm cryopreservation is generally obtained by masturbation. For many men, this may be an embarrassing or uncomfortable process (Williams [261]). It is critical that men understand how to collect semen and that they are offered a private and relaxing environment in which to do so.
For adolescent males, careful counselling as well as tactful and age‐appropriate instructions are necessary, as these patients are at risk for emotional distress from this process (Crawshaw and Hale [38]). Parents should be included in discussions, although separate sessions with the adolescent are often useful. Unfortunately, no guidelines exist on the best approach to semen cryopreservation in adolescent males, but individual institutional strategies are available.

Electroejaculation

In some patients who have suffered a spinal cord injury, ejaculation by masturbation is not an option for sperm collection. In this case, the ejaculatory nerves can be electrically stimulated using a low‐voltage rectal probe. This is usually sufficient to produce a semen ejaculate, although the quality of the ejaculate is often less using this method compared to masturbation (Brackett et al. [21]).

Microepididymal sperm aspiration

Microepididymal sperm aspiration (MESA) is a surgical procedure for collection of sperm when the ejaculatory tubes are blocked or have been interrupted by previous vasectomy (Bernie et al. [11]). A surgical incision is made into the outer covering of the testis and the epididymis is exposed; expanded areas of the epididymis likely to contain sperm are incised and the sperm is extracted (Bernie et al. [11]).

Percutaneous epididymal sperm aspiration

Percutaneous epididymal sperm aspiration (PESA) is a variant of MESA; rather than an incision, needle aspiration is used to extract sperm from the epididymis. PESA can be performed under local anaesthesia, but it is often the case that less sperm is collected using this approach (Esteves et al. [57]). Both MESA and PESA yield enough sperm for use with assisted reproductive techniques (ARTs) but not enough for a standard insemination (Bernie et al. [11], Esteves et al. [57]).

Testicular sperm extraction

For men who have a low sperm count, recovery of sperm from the epididymis may not be successful (Dabaja and Schlegel [39]). Testicular sperm extraction (TESE) and possibly tissue biopsy may be the best option for collecting sperm suitable for ARTs. The outer covering of the testicle is pulled back so that the seminiferous tubules can be visualized. An enlarged tubule is cut to permit sperm to flow from the tubule, where it can be aspirated (Schlegel [219]). Testicular tissue can be dissected in a culture dish and the released sperm collected for ARTs (Dabaja and Schlegel [39]). Some men with permanent azoospermia after chemotherapy can be successfully treated by TESE and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) (Meseguer et al. [143]).

Anticipated patient outcomes

Usually, a diagnosis and/or analysis of results in relation to fertility treatments is made available to patients after semen collection has taken place. Cryopreservation of semen gives patients the opportunity to conceive after fertility‐damaging treatment such as chemotherapy and/or radiotherapy.